Current Status
Not Enrolled
Enroll in this course to get access
Price
$69
Get Started
Jackson David Toof
Partner | ArentFox Schiff LLPCivility Under Pressure: Strategic Tactics for Handling Difficult Judges and Aggressive Attorneys | Live CLE Ethics Webinar
Broadcast Date: Tuesday, August 18, 2026, from 12:00 PM to 1:00 PM (ET) | On-Demand Available 24 Hours Later
Litigators and trial attorneys frequently face high-pressure courtroom dynamics, adversarial overreach, and complex interpersonal friction that can threaten the integrity of legal proceedings. Maintaining unwavering professionalism while zealously advocating for a client requires a deep understanding of legal ethics, local court rules, and strategic communication frameworks. When dealing with obstructionist opposing counsel or exceptionally demanding members of the bench, attorneys must navigate their duties to the court without compromising their client’s legal position or sacrificing procedural fairness.
In this CLE webinar, Jackson David Toof (ArentFox Schiff LLP) will draw on his extensive litigation and trial experience to provide actionable strategies for managing courtroom hostility and adversarial friction. Attendees will analyze applicable ethics standards, including Model Rules of Professional Conduct governing fairness to opposing counsel and tribunal decorum. The speaker will provide practical analysis regarding the preservation of the evidentiary record during contentious hearings, handling speaking objections, and utilizing specific procedural mechanisms to address unethical conduct. This program is designed for trial attorneys, litigators, and general practitioners seeking to maintain professional civility and ethical adherence while operating under intense litigation pressure.
Upon completion of this program, attorneys will be able to:
- Evaluate ethical boundaries under the Rules of Professional Conduct when responding to aggressive tactics from opposing counsel during discovery and trial.
- Apply legal and procedural mechanisms to manage hostile judicial temperament while safeguarding client rights and maintaining courtroom decorum.
- Execute record-preservation techniques to ensure judicial pushback or improper court rulings are properly documented for appellate review.
- Implement strategic advocacy tactics to defuse unprofessional behavior in depositions, oral arguments, and settlement negotiations.
- Identify procedural remedies—including motions for sanctions, protective orders, and recusal—to address severe misconduct or judicial bias within legal standards.
Agenda
Jackson David Toof, Partner, ArentFox Schiff LLP
1. Civility is a litigation skill, not a personality trait.
a. The presentation frames civility around the Model Rules (3.1, 3.4, 3.5, 8.4) and procedural tools (FRCP 11, 30(d), 37, 28 U.S.C. §§ 455, 1927), which reinforces that maintaining composure and professionalism is a strategic discipline grounded in enforceable rules — not just good manners.
b. As Chief Justice Burger put it, civility is the “lubricant” that keeps the adversary system functioning. Every time you stay measured while opposing counsel escalates, you are building credibility with the bench and creating a cleaner record for appeal.
2. The enforcement gap is the profession’s central challenge.
a.Twenty-four states require a civility oath, but only five allow discipline for uncivil conduct. California’s new annual re-attestation requirement is a significant step, but the California Supreme Court itself rejected the Task Force’s recommendation to make incivility grounds for formal discipline, citing free speech and vagueness concerns.
b. That tension — aspirational standards without enforcement teeth — means the real deterrents are judicial sanctions, reputational consequences, and case outcomes, not bar discipline.
3. The record is everything — and it starts before the courtroom.
a. Every email to opposing counsel is a potential exhibit to a sanctions motion.
b. The attorneys who won the sanctions ruling in Hindlin v. Prescription Songs prevailed in part because 187 improper speaking objections were documented on a single transcript.
c. Building a meticulous written record — in real time — is both the ethical obligation and the strategic advantage.
4.In-house counsel are watching.
a. Don’t risk your client’s corporate reputation with uncivil behavior.
b. The “red face test” — if you wouldn’t be comfortable standing up and arguing it before a judge, it shouldn’t be in the brief.
Why Attend This Webinar?
By attending this CLE Ethics webinar, you will:
- Earn CLE credit online from the comfort of your office or home.
- Access both the live webinar and the on-demand recording at your convenience.
- Gain practical strategies for managing hostile judicial temperaments, handling aggressive opposing counsel, preserving the record for appellate review, and maintaining professionalism in high-pressure litigation settings.
- Fulfill continuing legal education requirements in a practical, engaging format tailored to legal professionals.
Agenda
Jackson David Toof, Partner, ArentFox Schiff LLP
Who Should Attend
- Trial Attorneys and Commercial Litigators
- Civil Litigators and Appellate Attorneys
- In-House Counsel and Litigation Counsel
- Defense Attorneys and Plaintiff-Side Litigators
- Partners and Associates in Litigation Practice Groups
- Government Attorneys handling court proceedings and enforcement matters
- Legal Ethics and Professional Responsibility Practitioners
- Corporate Counsel managing disputes, depositions, and courtroom advocacy
Credit:
Course Level: Intermediate | Advance Preparation: Print and review course materials
Method of Presentation: Live Webinar | Prerequisite: None
Course Code: 1411774 | Total Credit: 1.0
CLE Credit:
CA 1.0 Civility in the Legal Profession – Approved Until: 08/18/2028
PA 1.0 Ethics – Approved Until: 08/18/2028
VT 1.0 Ethics – Approved Until: 12/31/2027
NJ 1.0 Ethics – Credits through Reciprocity
NY 1.0 Ethics and Professionalism – Credits through Reciprocity
AR 1.0 Ethics – Credits through Reciprocity
CT 1.0 Ethics – Credits through Reciprocity
NH 1.0 Ethics – Meets the requirements of NH Supreme Court Rule 53
MO 1.0 Ethics – Approved Until: 08/18/2026
Pending CLE Application: GA, TN, WI
Self-Apply: AL, CO, DE, FL, ID, IL, IN, IO, KS, KY, LA, NC, ME, MN, MS, MT, NE, NV, NM, ND, OH, OK, OR, SC, TX, UT, VA, WA, WV, WY
If you’d like us to apply for CLE, you may opt to pay the CLE processing fee here.
No MCLE Requirements: DC, MD, MA, MI, SD
Not Eligible for CLE: AK, AZ, HI
Instructions for Participating the Live Webinar
-
- Please Register for the course by clicking the "Take the Course" button if you have not already registered.
- Check Your Email – 24 hours before the webinar, you will receive an email with all necessary instructions, including access details and course materials. This information will also be posted on lesson when it is available.
- Download Course Materials – Course materials will be available for download **24-48 hours before** the live webinar. Be sure to review them in advance. The Link to download is available by clicking the lesson tab.
- Join the Webinar – Follow the instructions in the email to access the live broadcast at the scheduled time.
- Note the Secret Words – During the webinar, secret words will be announced periodically. Please write them down.
- Take the Quiz – After the webinar, click on the quiz link below and enter the secret words to complete the quiz.
- Print Your Certificate – Upon completing the quiz, you will be able to print your Certificate of Attendance, which includes instructions on how to obtain CLE, CPE, or other applicable credits for the course.
- On-Demand Access – The on-demand version of this course will be available 24-48 hours after the live webinar. If you miss the live presentation or need to review the content, you will have access to the on-demand version as an enrolled student. To access on-demand content, click the lesson and follow the instructions.
- Support: If you have any questions, please refer to the email instructions or contact support: support@theknowledgegroup.zohodesk.com.